Back when I joined Twitter – in the summer of 2008, although in Twitter years that’s almost a lifetime ago – few people had heard of it. These days its impossible to turn on the BBC without some mention of it; in fact, is there too much promotion of the microblogging service on the BBC?
After all, the BBC isn’t supposed to advertise anything (except its own services and a few public service subjects such as digital TV.) So how come almost every channel of the BBC seems to be relentlessly promoting a single online service these days?
The effect of the exposure generated by Jonathan Ross’ and Stephen Fry’s chat show conversation about Twitter is well known; several people have commented how, in the wake of that programme, Twitter now seems to be more of a British service than an American one such is the explosion of interest.
Even before the Ross/Fry interview there had been extensive news coverage of Twitter following the Hudson River plane crash where the BBC News interviewed the Twitter user who had posted the first reports and photo of the crash before the news networks could even locate the crash site with their cameras; and the broadcast even finished off with an “and finally” piece on Twitter itself. Even before this, Twitter had become a staple of BBC (and other) programmes on technology such as Digital Planet, Radio 5′s Pods and Blogs and the Guardian’s Tech Talk.
But recently Twitter’s broken out of the tech ghetto and flooded the BBC far wider than just the celeb geeks like Ross/Fry. Richard Bacon – who hosts the late night phone-in show on BBC Radio 5 Live – is a particular evangelist of the service and encourages messages through that medium through most of his shows. And now Simon Mayo has jumped on it as well, with his latest film review podcast with Dr Mark Kermode referring repeatedly to Twitter on a number of occasions. (Kermode, bless him, remains a bewildered sceptic unable to figure out how it all works.) There was even a mention of “twittering” on the BBC’s flagship radio comedy programme, The News Quiz, on Friday night.
As far as I know, Twitter did not feature in last night’s BAFTA coverage – at least, not explicitly. But Jonathan Ross had promised on Twitter to work in a word chosen by his followers into the broadcast, and by pure chance I happened to catch the moment when he did: the audience was bemused by his reference to “salad” when introducing the Best Costume category (“In my view, actors are in many ways like salad – they are nothing without great dressing”) but you could almost hear the virtual sequels of delight online.
So does it matter that the BBC is promoting Twitter on multiple TV and radio channels? After all, the BBC (as well as The Guardian, The Telegraph and many other media companies) produces literally hundreds of podcasts a week – and isn’t “podcasts” also promoting a commercial service, in that the name stems directly from Apple’s iPod? The iPod itself is rarely mentioned by name and the more generic “MP3 player” is used instead, so why not call podcasts “MP3 broadcasts” and avoid the advertising plug? Or how about the growing use of “Google” as a generic term for carrying out an internet search? Well, in both these cases case the media channels are just reflecting the reality, that “to podcast” and “to Google” are becoming embedded in everyday language, in the same way that “Hoover” still means a vacuum cleaner even in these days of Dyson.
In fact, trying to substitute generic terms for a commercial product can result in confusion. I remember as a kid watching Blue Peter on BBC1, and getting very confused about this “sticky back plastic” that they would go on about. Where could you find such a thing? I’m sure that one reason (or excuse) for not doing any of Blue Peter’s craft projects was because I didn’t have any “sticky back plastic” and didn’t know where to get any from and didn’t want to look stupid by asking. (I was only 5 at the time, after all; not that I’ve got a heck of a lot brighter since, but still.) Now, if they had said Sellotape – welll, I had drawers full of the stuff. But that wasn’t what they said, so it couldn’t be the thing to use, could it?
So you could use “microblogging service” instead of “Twitter” but how clunky is that? Not to mention that the BBC is using it as a cut-down version of email communication rather than a short blog, so “microblog” is actually inaccurate. No, the delight of Twitter is in many ways the name its chosen for itself, which captures brilliantly a light, playful, ephemeral nature that a generic term utterly fails to duplicate.
But why is the BBC – or any other media channel – giving so much free publicity to what is, after all, a single online service? It’s not like email where you can get the service from any one of thousands of vendors; it’s one specific site, one specific service. So to keep encouraging and promoting its use and uptake does seem like a strange thing for the BBC to be doing.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m not complaining – it’s nice to have Twitter being a success. Although at the same time, I already miss the days when it was just an in-secret among the more geeky online crowd where you felt you were eavesdropping on a niche club, rather than getting deafened by the roar on the mainstreet.
More from meHere's links to other things that I'm doing: my tweets, my reviews blog (Taking The Short View), my motor sports blog (motorsports.ind), my Google Shared items. Please check them out if any of them sound like your sort of thing!
See the latest stories I've been writing for crash.net on GP2, IndyCar and NASCAR.
- Taking The Short View looks to the stars with Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey S1 E1-5 (National Geographic) wp.me/p1lnud-Ls 21 hours ago
- Taking The Short View enjoys a relaxing midweek lie-in with a good book - The Hollywood Detective, by Martha… wp.me/p1lnud-Lk 1 day ago
- Taking The Short View turns back the clock for a little-seen British cult TV classic - The Nightmare Man (1981)… wp.me/p1lnud-Lp 2 days ago
- Tonight's #criminalminds going for some massively irritating jerky handheld cinematography. 3 days ago
- Taking The Short View shuffles on to a look back at The Walking Dead S4 E9-16 (Fox) wp.me/p1lnud-Lm 3 days ago
- A longer walk down memory lane than usual for the weekend: Taking The Short View recalls Babylon 5 (UK Watch) wp.me/p1lnud-Li 5 days ago
- Ahead of episode 2, Taking The Short View reviews Da Vinci's Demons S2 E1 "The Blood of Man" (Fox) wp.me/p1lnud-Lg 6 days ago
- Taking The Short View looks at the first two slices of the latest serving of Nordic Noir, Mammon (More 4) wp.me/p1lnud-Le 1 week ago
- Why can't I shake the compete conviction that today is Thursday? 1 week ago
- Taking The Short View returns with a generally positive look at Shetland S2 (BBC One) wp.me/p1lnud-Lc 1 week ago
- Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey S1 E1-5 (National Geographic) April 17, 2014
- The Hollywood Detective, by Martha Steinway April 16, 2014
- The Nightmare Man (1981) (BBC) April 15, 2014
- The Walking Dead S4 E9-16 (Fox) April 14, 2014
- Babylon 5 (UK Watch) April 12, 2014
- Da Vinci’s Demons S2 E1 “The Blood of Man” (Fox) April 11, 2014
- Mammon S1 E1-2 (More 4) April 10, 2014
- Shetland S2 (BBC One) April 9, 2014
- The Lies of Locke Lamora, by Scott Lynch/The Painted Man, by Peter V Brett March 25, 2014
- Ender’s Game (2013) [Blu-ray] March 23, 2014
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
- Will the 2012 Bahrain GP take place? April 10, 2012
- A first look at the 2012 season form book March 17, 2012
- Sutil convicted over nightclub fracas January 31, 2012
- A slumbering blog December 8, 2011
- Future/Present: who will be the faces of tomorrow’s F1? July 30, 2011
- F1: Sky finally claim the Grand Prix July 29, 2011
- NASCAR: Loudon success rejuvenates Stewart-Haas July 18, 2011
- INDYCAR: Recriminations rage on after Toronto July 15, 2011
- Comment on Will the 2012 Bahrain GP take place? by Bahraini youth vow ‘three days of rage’ during Formula 1 « This Day – One Day April 13, 2012
- Comment on F1: Sky finally claim the Grand Prix by andrewlewin November 1, 2011
- Comment on F1: Sky finally claim the Grand Prix by Chris Williams November 1, 2011
My Flickr Photos
Most read posts
Archives by Month
Archives by Subject
- What to do about a problem like HMV?
- End of the road for HMV?
- Surbiton: Easter bridge replacement project 2012
- Keep Calm. But there’s no more carrying on
- And the word was good
- COI: letting go and saying farewell
- iSuccession: Steve Jobs’ final big achievement
- links for 2011-06-22
- Writing sense out of chaos
- Doctor Who – What, and Where Next?