The Twitter-isation of the news
The way that two big news stories in the past week were covered on BBC News have made me realise: not only is Twitter no passing fad, but it even may be having an irrevocable effect on mainstream journalism.
The first story was the limited Cabinet reshuffle undertaken by Gordon Brown; and the second was four days later with the build up to the announcement of the UK plan to bail out banks to the tune of £50bn. In both cases, the BBC opted to lead their news coverage of the story with a live text “as it happened” format. This takes the form of a whole sequence of brief one-paragraph time-stamped entry, from multiple sources including text contributors, and with the most recent addition at the top. Sound familiar? It should – it’s the very essence of how Twitter works. It’s most definitely microblogging.
This is the first time I can recall seeing this approach used for serious, heavyweight stories. But it’s not new on the BBC site as a whole: it’s been used for sports coverage for some time now, and was the main way I followed the Euro 2008 football in the summer, long before I’d even heard of Twitter. I’m not a huge fan of football, but I found the live text feed from the BBC to be lively, funny and engrossing all by itself.
Nor did the BBC pioneer this format as a way of covering sporting events. When I first got online in the mid-90s it was to get more information about Formula 1, and the official FIA site had a ‘lap-by-lap’ summary for journalists to download immediately after every Grand Prix. And all they were doing was delivering material online they had been producing offline for years.
Ironically, just as this sort of thing becomes popular and mainstream, the FIA no longer provide this service for F1 – because they think a traditional website with live timing streams is the way of the future. But meanwhile, back at the BBC, they’ve picked up the baton and now provide their own, unofficial live text coverage of the Grand Prix.
The crossover of the live text microblogging approach seemed to come during the recent US Presidential Debates. Actually you can see why: these theatrical, staged gladiatorial occasions are the perfect blend of showbiz and sport in a news and political affairs wrapper. Just to prove how ideal this subject is, Twitter has since jumped on its own band wagon with a special US Election Twitter feed.
As to whether Twitter is the cause of this change of mainstream media, or just a parallel or coincidental development – I grant you, it’s impossible to prove either way. But I would assert that the timing of this ‘jump’ of microblogging is not a coincidence and wouldn’t have happened if journalists weren’t aware of and using Twitter. Twitter’s success – and the fact that it’s trendy in media circles right now – gives the BBC the license it needs to try microblogging on serious news pages without getting laughed out of town. Instead of being perceived as an old sports-only method of reporting, it can be positioned instead as the BBC cannily judging the zeitgeist and jumping on board at the perfect moment. The BBC are trailblazers at identifying new trends and tools, from showing the financial crisis in graphics to the use of video clips and user-generated content, wide provision of RSS and Twitter alert feeds, and how their blogs have become famous for breaking world exclusives thanks to Nick Robinson and Robert Peston. As far as web 2.0 goes it has no greater, more enthusiastic or – crucially – more effective champion than Auntie.
So if you accept that microblogging is becoming increasingly the way of covering news stories as well as sports, the question that immediately comes to mind is: is this a good thing? Or is it another sign of “dumbing down”?
I’ll nail my colours to the mast and say that I believe it is a very good thing. I wouldn’t want it to replace a follow-up considered analysis piece to bring it all together at the end of the day, but for a breaking story that’s moving fast then I think microblogging is ideal. With the traditional approach, a journalist would have to keep coming back to the article and updating it. Maybe the lead hasn’t changed, but some stories further down have been updated. Would a casual reader know where to look, what’s changed – or would they conclude it’s the story that they have already read? No such danger with a microblog: all you have to do it read the first paragraph to know if it is new or not.
I’d also argue that – far from being “dumbing down” – microblogging in the news environment actually allows greater, more detailed and in-depth coverage of the story in question. That is does it in an easy-to-access wrapper is just the bonus prize.
For example, take NASCAR (no, really stick with me here.) A typical NASCAR race is almost four hours long, usually a couple of hundred laps or more. The typical newspaper report on the race will cover: any notable incidents (i.e. wrecks); the story of the final couple of laps to say who won; and a bunch of quotes from drivers. If you’re lucky, the combined material will provide a coverage of perhaps ten per cent of the full race length; it will necessarily miss out any subtlety of the ebb and flow of the race, and will overlook any driver not directly affected by the wrecks or the final result. It’s a very incomplete experience.
Not so with the lap-by-lap summary that NASCAR still produce for their races: compare the lap-by-lap for the most recent race at Talladega with the traditional news piece on the race post-event. The level of detail and information is chalk and cheese. Not that I’m saying that one is better than the other, just that they offer different experiences with the feature piece summarising, analysing and filtering, while the real reporting of the event is handled in the lap-by-lap. You can have a hybrid piece as well, which is what I end up doing for my own race reports – you can compare motorsportind’s Talladega race report with the above to see what I’m getting at.
Ironically then, it seems that microblogging is a return to actual reporting of fast moving events, while the other pieces are analysis or comment that have become confused/synonymous with journalism only in the last couple of decades. Journalism has come home to the future, and it matches perfectly the emerging online set-up: live text is to Twitter as analysis/comment is to blogs. This blog post started with a couple of quick tweets about the BBC’s Bank plan coverage – and has now emerged, a few days later, as a full blog article.
Are there any breaking news stories that it would be inappropriate – tasteless, even – to tackle with a microblogging format? I honestly can’t think of any. A terrorist attack? A pandemic? A high-profile celebrity death such as that of Princess Diana in 1997? Far from being inappropriate, these are exactly the time when I would want the story rolled out at high speed and not wait around for it to be crafted into a careful narrative.
So perhaps one day – pretty soon – we’ll see online news sites recast as all microblogging coverage upfront, backed by in-depth feature pieces. Sounds good to me – that’s a site I’d certainly be checking out on a regular basis.
[UPDATE: Interesting to see Thompson Reuters inviting social media reps to a news event on the present economic crisis and given unprecedented access to the event and asked to utilise social media apps ranging from Twitter and Plurk to Seesmic and 12seconds in order to facilitate conversations around the day.]
More from meHere's links to other things that I'm doing: my tweets, my reviews blog (Taking The Short View), my motor sports blog (motorsports.ind), my Google Shared items. Please check them out if any of them sound like your sort of thing!
See the latest stories I've been writing for crash.net on GP2, IndyCar and NASCAR.
- Taking The Short View meets Colonel March of Scotland Yard takingtheshortview.wordpress.com/2017/04/26/col… 1 hour ago
- Second barrage of hail. Some mean looking chunks of ice in this lot, too! 2 hours ago
- Sudden hailstorm in #Surbiton. I though tit was rather cold today... 3 hours ago
- Taking The Short View reads Noah Hawley's "Before The Fall" takingtheshortview.wordpress.com/2017/04/25/bef… 1 day ago
- Taking The Short View revisits James Burke's 1978 classic science history series "Connections" takingtheshortview.wordpress.com/2017/04/24/con… 2 days ago
- Possibly the most in-sync we've ever been on an episode of #doctorwho! twitter.com/frameratedUK/s… 3 days ago
- Taking The Short View keeps on smiling with Doctor Who S10 E2 takingtheshortview.wordpress.com/2017/04/23/doc… https://t.co/2HmcrtqQPc 3 days ago
- #Hinterland really is a most excellent drama. And tonight's possibly one of the best yet. 6 days ago
- Literally an example of turkeys being happy to vote for Christmas. twitter.com/SkyNewsBreak/s… 1 week ago
- As May trashes Fixed Terms, is there anything left of Cameron's legacy? Except same-sex marriage. Doubtless she'll see to that after June 9. 1 week ago
- Colonel March of Scotland Yard (1954-1956) April 26, 2017
- Before the Fall, by Noah Hawley April 25, 2017
- Connections (BBC One) (1978) April 24, 2017
- Doctor Who S10E2 “Smile” (BBC One) April 23, 2017
- Doctor Who S10 E1 “The Pilot” (BBC One) April 16, 2017
- Oasis E1 “Pilot” (Amazon Prime), and The Book of Strange New Things by Michel Faber April 12, 2017
- Sneaky Pete S1 (Amazon Prime) April 5, 2017
- Top Gear S24 E1-4 (BBC 2) March 30, 2017
- Watching the detectives: Line of Duty; Follow the Money; The Team; Broadchurch; Vera March 29, 2017
- Ronja, The Robbers Daughter (Amazon Prime) March 3, 2017
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
- Will the 2012 Bahrain GP take place? April 10, 2012
- A first look at the 2012 season form book March 17, 2012
- Sutil convicted over nightclub fracas January 31, 2012
- A slumbering blog December 8, 2011
- Future/Present: who will be the faces of tomorrow’s F1? July 30, 2011
- F1: Sky finally claim the Grand Prix July 29, 2011
- NASCAR: Loudon success rejuvenates Stewart-Haas July 18, 2011
- INDYCAR: Recriminations rage on after Toronto July 15, 2011
- Comment on Will the 2012 Bahrain GP take place? by Bahraini youth vow ‘three days of rage’ during Formula 1 « This Day – One Day April 13, 2012
- Comment on F1: Sky finally claim the Grand Prix by andrewlewin November 1, 2011
- Comment on F1: Sky finally claim the Grand Prix by Chris Williams November 1, 2011
My Flickr Photos
Most read posts
Archives by Month
Archives by Subject
- What to do about a problem like HMV?
- End of the road for HMV?
- Surbiton: Easter bridge replacement project 2012
- Keep Calm. But there’s no more carrying on
- And the word was good
- COI: letting go and saying farewell
- iSuccession: Steve Jobs’ final big achievement
- links for 2011-06-22
- Writing sense out of chaos
- Doctor Who – What, and Where Next?